Jump to content
tanknet.org

What Was The Nazis' Desired End-State?


Recommended Posts

France and Britain were pretty well equipped and prepared they just got the German game plan completly wrong.

 

If they had stuck with sanctions would the Germans have had to worry about anglo-french bombers given the real reluctance the Anglo-French had for making war.?

 

Yes, France and Britain got completely wrong footed (and were totally out-fought) by the Germans in 1939/1940, but well equipped? Hardly.

 

The French in particular were dealing with massive inertial - political, industrial, strategic, technical - that meant that the majority of their armed forces were either equipped with obsolescent materiel or were hamstrung by poor doctrine and training.

 

Aviation is my area of interest, so I'll use that as an example.

 

In the early 1930s, the French aviation industry was well established, relatively modern and had a large enough industrial base that it could potentially be expanded to put the vast amount of modern aircraft that a 1940s style war required.

 

However, mismanagement, underinvestment and political favouritism for certain projects/manufacturers through the 1930s, combined with the disastrous nationalisation in 1936, resulted in an industry that was ill-suited to France's pre-war needs.

 

The French went into war with a bomber force that was almost completely obsolete, almost no ground attack aircraft, a fighter arm equipped with decidedly second rate locally-designed fighters and a second tier US design (and I love the P-36, that's not a slander against it), engines that were underpowered, a C&C system that belonged in the 1920s and only the vaguest concept of combined arms doctrine.

 

If the French and English had been well equipped in the air, there would have been no need for their shopping expeditions to the US in the late 1930s, to get the fighters, bombers and reconnaissance aircraft they needed to fight a modern war.

 

France was aiming have a core 'modern' airforce in place by about the end of 1941, and even that was probably too ambitious given the state its industry was in by early 1940.

Edited by Jabberwocky
Link to post
Share on other sites

It would be interesting to see what JA war planning was vs the USSR by 1941. The army staff would have continued to update planning, even as the Imperial Council drifted more toward the Southern Plan. The immensity of Mongolia seems to make it a non-starter, and I'd say ditto vs the fortified zones surrounding Vladivostok. The Trans-Siberian RR might have invited a thrust to the NNE, but one still has a tiger by the tail.

 

Had a beer-infused conversation with a Taiwanese friend who had exited the academia but was previously a specialist in Manchuria between Japanese colonialism and Chinese Civil War. According to him at least some of the original documents from IJA war planning exercises are still extant. His impression from reading the secondary literature is that after Khalkhin Gol, all IJA plans for a Russian War were predicated on the Wehrmacht crushing the Soviets in the West, leaving the IJA to pick off the remains of the Russian Far Eastern Empire, which falls into line with actual policy of not going to war against Russia for Germany.

Link to post
Share on other sites
The army staff would have continued to update planning, even as the Imperial Council drifted more toward the Southern Plan. The immensity of Mongolia seems to make it a non-starter, and I'd say ditto vs the fortified zones surrounding Vladivostok. The Trans-Siberian RR might have invited a thrust to the NNE, but one still has a tiger by the tail.

 

According to him at least some of the original documents from IJA war planning exercises are still extant. His impression from reading the secondary literature is that after Khalkhin Gol, all IJA plans for a Russian War were predicated on the Wehrmacht crushing the Soviets in the West, leaving the IJA to pick off the remains of the Russian Far Eastern Empire, which falls into line with actual policy of not going to war against Russia for Germany.

 

 

Very interesting, it would be great to have more details on Japanese planning against the USSR. I have read in several books that another reason for opting out was the situation in China, which absorbed large quantities of Army resources. The Navy would be able to help against European colonies in SE Asia.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 weeks later...

So what did Hitler actually see as the best possible outcome for Germany in WW2?

 

* Think of Eastern Europe as Sparta: Germans as the dominating martial race living in fortified cities, Slavs working as (even more) unfree rural and mining workers.

* Germany in its Western borders of 1914.

* USA, France and United Kingdom defeated militarily to 'settle which nation is superior and dominant'.

* Italians are left to dominate the Mediterranean world, albeit not the critical Romanian oil fields. The Italian/Roman Empire would be decidedly junior to the German one due to less natural resources and little industrial capacity.

 

No German language in UK or USA planned, ever. No invasion of UK or USA planned, ever.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 years later...

** Shagazaam! **

 

The article is rather breathless in its conclusions, but the book itself is an interesting find.

 

What Hitler had planned for North America: Canada's archive acquires Nazi research book

 

Once part of Adolf Hitler’s personal library, the 1944 volume reports on the Jewish population of various cities

The Canadian Press Updated: January 24, 2019

OTTAWA — Canada’s national archive has acquired a rare book it believes could have served as a blueprint for a Nazi purge of Jews in North America.

 

Once part of Adolf Hitler’s personal library, the 1944 volume reports on the Jewish population of various cities as well as key organizations and newspapers serving Canadian and American Jewish communities.

 

The 137-page German-language book, Statistics, Media, and Organizations of Jewry in the United States and Canada, was compiled by researcher Heinz Kloss, who did field work in the U.S. in the late 1930s.

 

The research was carried out for the Nazi regime and hints at what might have happened in North America if the Allies had lost the Second World War, Library and Archives Canada says.

 

The book lists general population figures, as well as the number of Jews, in dozens of Canadian cities large and small, from Vancouver to Glace Bay, N.S. It also details ethnic backgrounds and the languages people spoke.

 

“This information would have been the building blocks to rolling out the Final Solution in Canada, allowing perpetrators of the Holocaust to know what cities to go to to find Jewish people and how many Jews to round up,” said Michael Kent, a curator at Library and Archives Canada.

 

[...]

 

The bookplate features a stylized eagle, swastika and the words Ex Libris Adolf Hitler, indicating it came from the Nazi leader’s collection.

 

An American soldier likely plucked the volume from Hitler’s library at his alpine retreat near Berchtesgaden, as thousands of books were taken as war souvenirs in 1945, Library and Archives says.

 

The Canadian institution bought the book for about $6,000 from a reputable dealer who obtained it as part of a collection owned by a Holocaust survivor, Kent said. The dealer, who trades exclusively in Judaica, was keen to see the volume go to a Jewish institution or another appropriate memory institution.

 

[...]

 

Kent said there is no evidence Kloss visited Canada, but he developed strong ties with American Nazi sympathizers and clearly accessed secondary sources in his research. The book includes the 1931 Census of Canada and the 1937 Report of the Immigration Branch among its Canadian references.

 

The fragile volume, printed on wartime paper, required extensive restoration work before it could be handled and displayed, Kent said.

 

[...]

 

hitler_book_20190123.jpg

 

https://calgaryherald.com/news/canada/canadas-archive-buys-1944-book-that-hints-at-nazi-plans-for-north-america/wcm/de6c29ba-52fa-4439-bc8c-d2096c87e5d7

Link to post
Share on other sites

Would very much like to read more regarding the ongoing planning of the Strike North faction after the defeats in 1939. Lessons learned, and just as importantly, what to expect, from ground combat operations against Russian forces would be invaluable for rematch preparations.

 

The performance of the IJAAF against the Soviet Air Force was generally favorable in 1939. Conditions in 1941 would be drastically more so, both quantitatively, thanks to the addition of IJNAF forces to the available aircraft for battle, and quantitatively, thanks to the Luftwaffe.

 

Logistically, with entire Russian armies being consumed in the far West, the Japanese would potentially be operating much closer to their supply bases in Northeast Asia than Russian forces at the extreme far East and dependent on the vulnerable Trans-Siberian for supply. The rail and rolling stock requirements alone for Russia to supply a 2-front war would potentially be enormous.

 

Regarding Vladivostok, the Japanese High Command could only hope that Russia and Russians would commit every last Siberian division east of Khabarovsk in its defense, as there would be no better place on Earth for battle between Japan and Russia in 1941.

Edited by Nobu
Link to post
Share on other sites

 

The widespread records destruction in 1945 by the Japanese makes that a difficult matter.

That is so true. I wish more records had survived.

 

Or that those involved in the planning had later written about it, but they kept their mouths shut and did not write to keep the secrets.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The Nazis produced something called Generalplan Ost which was a blueprint for what German lebensraum in the East was going to look like.

 

Broadly, it identified that if the occupied territories were to produce a significant food surplus for export back to Germany then it would be impossible to feed the urban populations of Belarus, Ukraine and Poland. At least 50% of the population of these areas was therefore to be eliminated with starvation being suggested as the easiest method. Some ethnic groups such as the Jews were to be exterminated completely. The final death toll would be approximately 10 times the number of people murdered by the Nazis during WW2. The remaining population were to be kept alive to provide slave labor to their new Germanic overlords.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...